Favorites: The Babysitters Club

This week’s favorites feature includes our 4 favorite ladies from the BSC: Claudia Kishi, Stacey McGill (obviously the top two), Mary Ann Spier, and Dawn Schafer. Each with their own unique styles, we thought: what would each of them be wearing today?



Claudia was all about being as loud as possible style-wise. How can we forget her themed outfits (surely you haven’t forgotten the classic Under-the-Sea ensemble), DIY jewelry, junk food stashes and that major sister complex? Betsey Johnson is surely one of Claudia’s favorite designers, right? The mismatched earrings are SO KISHI!
1. Sparkle and Fade Mesh Dolman Sweater :: Urban Outfitters
2. Pelican Hat Mismatch Earrings :: Betsey Johnson
3. Plastik Hearts Tote :: Betsey Johnson
4. ASOS Leggings in Mono Stripe Print :: ASOS
5. Kimchi Blue Alice Lace-ups :: Urban Outfitters


Everyone loves Stacey (am I right?) this New York girl oozes confidence through her chic fashion sense, despite her parents divorce and early onset diabetes; we have to give it to her, when life hands Stacey lemons, she makes (sugar-free) lemonade!!
6. Aztec Cut Out Earrings :: Top Shop
7. Multi-Floral Pleat Front Shell :: Top Shop
8. Panelled Matt Wetlook Leggings :: Top Shop
9. LEI Two Part Platforms :: Top Shop
10. Art Deco Wrist Purse :: Top Shop


The best little tree hugger from the 90s (although a close call with Z.Z. Ziff from Salute Your Shorts) is totally into Free People. She has that cool bohemian with a little girly edge down pat. Our favorite part about Dawn was her haunted farmhouse with all those secret passageways. Too bad she had to leave it all behind for the beaches of California.
11. Addie Bibbed Henley :: Anthropologie
12. JadeTribe Capri Weekender Bag ::Free People
13. Cascade Mini Wedge :: Free People
14. Battenburg Crochet Shorts :: Free People


A modern Mary Ann Spier could most certainly find any of her demure fashions at Modcloth! From Peter Pan collars to bows to knee socks they’ve got it all. Not sure she’d be this fashion forward, but people can change, right? P.S. Pretty sure that darling bracelet was given to her by the best boyfriend of all time, Logan Bruno. Awwwwww!
15. With a Little Lock Necklace :: Modcloth
16. Basically Amazing Socks :: Modcloth
17. Banner Day Dress :: Modcloth
18. Right Here Heel :: Modcloth
We’re going to go dig out our Super Specials and head to the pool. Who was your favorite character? Are you sad we left out that bossy Kristy?